Monday, May 18, 2009

Prescription Drugs: Risk vs. Benefit vs Cost- The Chantix Example

When a physician prescribes a medication, a patient generally wants the most effective medication, with the least amount of side effects, that won't cost a lot of money. Unfortunately, this is often not the case. When determining which medication is right for you, all things need to be balanced. Obviously, for people with good prescription coverage and/or substantial wealth, cost likely does not play into the picture. However, for most patients, decisions need to be made. Should a patient take a generic medication that might not work as well or have potentially more side effects, but will cost substantially less than the branded medication? The choice is not always easy.

The Chantix example

I have posted several times about Chantix here, here, here, and here. The main reasons for these postings was due to the fact that the media (and some organizations) in my opinion were blowing out of proportion the risk of side effects of a very useful medication for the single leading preventable cause of death in our country.

Now, we have data in that seems to confirm that Chantix is the most effective agent available in the United States for smoking cessation. For those of you not familiar with the Cochrane group, they are international and free of any commercial bias. They review all data available in a systematic way, and are considered by most as some of the most unbiased and highest level of evidence available for therapeutics. The Cochrane review for Chantix (varenicline) is now in, and states that compared to placebo, nicotine replacement or bupropion (Wellbutrin, Zyban), that Chantix is the most effective agent, essentially doubling to tripling your chances of successfully quitting cigarettes.

Soon after Chantix had been on the market, reports of worsening of neuropsychiatric symptoms (depression, anxiety, suicidal ideation) surfaced, and the FDA took notice. Unfortunately, they went very public with this and the media had a field day scaring a lot of patients. In the original studies, patients with underlying depression and anxiety were purposefully excluded. Yet, patients with mental health disorders are much more likely to be smokers. We also know that stopping smoking, even without medication, can cause a worsening of these symptoms. In their final analysis, the FDA stated that it was not entirely clear whether Chantix was responsible for some of these adverse events. They appropriately added language to the drug information (package insert) to warn doctors and patients to look out for these side effects. This is a good thing, because even if Chantix is not the causative agent, it serves as a reminder that stopping smoking can cause worsening of neuropsychiatric symptoms.

Thus, the issue becomes efficacy vs. safety. Should you take a medication that is the most effective agent to help you stop smoking and risk a potential side effect that you could become depressed or even suicidal? One also has to consider the risks of NOT taking the drug. If I don't take Chantix, for example, and continue smoking, I am at risk for a lot of major problems! Given that it is unclear that Chantix has any more or less risk than other agents or no agents at all, in my opinion, since smoking increases risks for things like cancer, heart attack and stroke; in this case risk is outweighed by benefit.

Probably more troublesome is efficacy vs. cost. Chantix trumped bupropion (wellbutrin, zyban) and nicotine replacement (patch, gum, etc.). However, bupropion is generic and for most patients with prescription coverage, a relatively low out of pocket expense. Nicotine replacement is not covered by insurance, and thus the patch, gum or lozenge is a high out of pocket expense. Finally, many insurances still do not cover Chantix, and when covered the co-pay can be high. Thus, do you take the medicine is that is likely to be the most effective, but pay more, or do you try the generic which will likely work, though possibly not as well?

It would be great if all medicines were covered and at low costs to patients, worked incredibly well with virtually no side effects. However, in general this is just not the case. Many generics work just as well if not better than newer more expensive drugs. However, this is not always the situation. Furthermore, sometimes more effective drugs come to market but with increased risk. Doctors and patients must weigh cost, benefit, and risk with each prescription. Every patient's situation will be different. Thus, when being prescribed a new drug you need to take all of these into account.

Here are some questions to ask:
1. What are the side effects of the drug, and what is the chance that I will get these side effects?
2. What are the benefits of this drug, and how much and how likely will I benefit if I take this drug?
3. What are the risks if I don't take this drug, and how likely am I to get these consequences?
4. Are there alternatives available for this drug? If so, what would my out of pocket costs be for each one?
5. What are the differences in risk and benefits between all my options, including not taking any medication?


Mr. MedSaver said...

One thing that makes the cost of Chantix slightly different is the fact that it will save you money in the long run . . . because you won't be purchasing cigarettes anymore.

Of course, I try to explain this to people constantly. I tell them to think of it as a short-term investment rather than a healthcare expense. And then they just roll their eyes, and tell me to put the Rx on hold.

Lee McAlilly said...

Dr. Mintz,

I found your blog when doing searches on hypertension. I was impressed by the depth of your post (i.e. 4 Things the FDA Should Go After Besides Cheerios).

I'm currently recruiting people to become official Everyday Health bloggers and wanted to see if you'd be interested. It would give you a large audience and platform to promote your site. Please email me at lmcalilly (at ) waterfrontmedia (dot) com if you're interested in finding out more.


Lee McAlilly
Everyday Health Blog Coordinator

chantix said...

A whole array of factors are found to be responsible for causing infertility in men as well as women and among all these causes of infertility, eating disorders such as bulimia nervosa and norexia nervosa, stress, rigorous exercising, intake of alcohol and smoking are found to be prominently responsible for infertility. However, specific details related to smoking and infertility reveals that smoking reduces sperm production in men and makes them infertile and in case of women, smoking is found to be responsible for decreasing the quality of eggs and with smoking reducing the quality of eggs in women, they fall prey to infertility easily.

Alena said...

I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don't know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.


Dendur said...

Pain pills without prescription are widely used in all countries, especially in the U.S. where the economy people look for your home, as the situation facing this country still is not the best, with more reason, if the medicines they need are controlled as vicodin, hydrocodone, tramadol, lortab, Percocet, etc. Therefore, in findrxonline suggest that these medications for chronic pain are very effective, but they also are very controlled should be priority for people in need.

Ashley said...

That’s a great info. Thanks for sharing, really like your view. I can see that you are putting a lot of time and effort into your blog.

Keep posting the good work.

Medtipster said...

I happened upon your blog while doing research on the effectiveness of generic drugs when compared to 'branded' medications.
I must admit, I found your blog to be rather informative. Thanks for sharing.
If you can, drop me a line - your opinion will be appreciated.

Anonymous said...

For me, if the drug is worth the price, I would prefer it even though it has a generic counterpart. As a consumer, I'm always after drug efficacy. I think part also of the reasons consumers buy branded products, aside from potency of the drug, is that they are safe to take because they pass through stringent quality control procedures such as the near infrared spectroscopy of the NIR technology. With the case of which drugs to help me quit smoking, I would prefer the branded pharmaceutical product over its equivalent generic because I consider it a better risk in terms of long-term positive results.